Despite almost global reticule over seemingly baseless, often rambling tweets, President Donald Trump has actually increased his Twitter activity in recent months. The impact of these knee-jerk, fire-from-the-hip responses has always been pondered, but now we finally may have definitive proof of the tweets’ effects on the bond market.
Most recently, Trump has pounded his followers and the Twitterverse with aggressive ramblings on the nature of the United States’ trade relationship with China. Additionally, the Federal Reserve has been lined up in the scope sights. An analysis of these tweets was recently released, here is the 4-1-1 on the report:
The Algorithm, the Volatility, and the Federal Reserve
JP Morgan, in an attempt to quantify President Trump’s tweet impact, analyzed over 14,000 tweets in what they are calling the “Volfefe Index” (a combination of the word “volatility” and Trump’s infamous “covfefe” tweet) – analyzing how the President’s tweets are influencing volatility in U.S. interest rates. Here is a deeper summary from CNBC:
J.P. Morgan found that the index, named after Trump’s infamous and still mysterious “covfefe” tweet, explains a measurable fraction of the moves in implied rate volatility for 2-year and 5-year Treasurys.
“This makes rough sense as much of the president’s tweets have been focused on the Federal Reserve, and as trade tensions are broadly seen as, first and foremost, impactful on near-term economic performance and, likewise, the Fed’s reaction to such developments,” wrote the authors of the J.P. Morgan report.
And here is an excellent summary from Business Insider, including some quotes from the piece::
- “We can train a classifier to infer how likely each tweet is to move markets,” JPMorgan said in a note to clients.
- Certain words had more of an effect on markets, including China, trade, and Mueller.
- “A broad swath of assets from single-name stocks to macro products have found their price dynamics increasingly beholden to a handful of tweets from the commander in chief.”
A Visual Representation, and More Details
Visual learner? No problem! Shortly after the news broke in September, Bloomberg released an excellent review video covering the results. In the write-up, Bloomberg explains CitiGroup Inc has joined the efforts of JP Morgan by clarifying a few points. Most specifically, the impact of Trump’s tweets can squarely be set on Treasury yields. Yikes. If you don’t understand the importance of Treasury yields for America’s economy, here is a basic summary from Investopedia:
- A treasury bond is a certificate representing a loan to the federal government that matures in more than 10 years.
- Since they are backed by the U.S. government, they are seen as a safe investment, particularly relative to stocks and other securities.
- Treasury bond prices and yields move in opposite directions—falling prices boost yields and rising prices lower yields.
- The 10-year yield is used as a proxy for mortgage rates, and other measures; it’s also seen as a sign of investor sentiment about the economy.
- A rising yield indicates falling rates and falling demand for Treasury bonds, which means investors would rather put their money in higher risk, higher reward investments; a falling yield suggests the opposite.
Back to Bloomberg, here is a snippet from the piece that also provides additional clarity:
They found that the Volfefe Index can account for a “measurable fraction” of moves in implied volatility, seen in interest rate derivatives known as swaptions. That’s particularly apparent at the shorter end of the curve, with two- and five-year rates more impacted than 10-year securities.
Highly recommend viewing the charts they’ve put together for a better visual on this impact, it is real!
Other Info and Key Data Relevant to Volfefe
Brace yourselves – this isn’t exactly shocking in terms of the impact of Trump’s tweets on the economy. Vox reports that Bank of America recently told clients in a note that the stock market tends to fall slightly on the days Trump tweets a lot more.
Some key info from that report:
- Bank of America says that “since 2016, days with more than 35 tweets (90 percentile) by Trump have seen negative returns (-9bp).”
- “Days with less than 5 tweets (10 percentile) have seen positive returns (+5bp) — statistically significant,” the brokerage’s chief stock strategist, Savita Subramanian, says.
- Overall, President Trump’s tenure has been good for the stock market with the Dow up 42% since the 2016 presidential election.
Will this news slow down Trump’s proclivity to tweet? “Signs point to no.”
If you found our blog looking for financial advice or assistance with credit card debt relief or debt consolidation, call Golden Financial Services today at (866)-376-9846 or firstname.lastname@example.org. You can check out the rest of our blog here, and do your research on our services here. Let’s talk soon!